12 Angry Men (1957)

rob challengeThis week on the challenge Rob pick one of the all time classic 12 Angry Men ranked number 5 on the IMDB all time greatest film voted for by fans a like.

logoDirectorSidney Lumet

Writer: Reginald Rose (Screenplay)

Starring: Martin Balsam, John Fiedler, Lee J Cobb, E.G. Marshall, Jack Klugman, Edward Binns, Jack Warden, Henry Fonda, Joseph Sweeney, Ed Begley, George Vokovec, Robert Webber

Plot: A dissenting juror in a murder trial slowly manages to convince the others that the case is not as obviously clear as it seemed in court.

There may be spoilers the rest of the review

Verdict: Masterpiece

Story: 12 Angry Men starts with our jury being taken to the jury room to make their verdict. Early conversations discuss the idea that the case being cut and dry, but when the first vote goes up only eleven men pick guilty while one man stands up and votes not guilty. He wants to discuss the case before making it quick decision on whether to send the accused the death row.

As the 12 men discuss the case the solo juror that stood up against the guilty verdict slowly starts to talk the rest of the jury into looking at the facts of the case and slowly starts to turn the jury.

12 Angry Men is one of the simplest stories you will ever see, it also takes a fresh turn on a trial film. On paper this could sound very boring, and it would be hard to talk anyone out of that, but once you watch this you will not be able t look away. When you look at what this film achieves you will bee impressed too a new level and even with this film being nearly 60 years old it hasn’t dated a single bit. (10/10)

Actor Review

Full Cast: 12 Angry Men only uses the 12 actors and I don’t think it would be fair to judge each individual performance because this could easily be the best ensemble cast of all time, each character has their different background and opinion on what is the outcome of the case. Every single cast member does a brilliant job showing just how intense being stuck on a jury can be.cast

Director Review: Sidney Lumet – Sidney gives us one of the greatest films ever put onto film, end of discussion. (10/10)

Crime: 12 Angry Men shows the 12 juror discussing a criminal case while making final verdict, this is a great insight into how they would have got to the final out come. (10/10)

Drama: 12 Angry Men gets top marks for this brilliant piece of work. (10/10)

Settings: 12 Angry Men uses just the jury room for the whole setting giving us an insight to just the conversation between the jurors. (10/10)

Suggestion: 12 Angry Men is a must watch for all the film fans out there I do still think casual film fans might find it not their cup of tea. (Watch)

Best Part: The performances are all brilliant.

Worst Part: No, isn’t one.

Believability: While I have been on a jury and understand how the discussion take place this cold very well be how intense it gets in there. (10/10)

Chances of Tears: No (0/10)

Chances of Sequel: No

Post Credits Scene: No

Oscar Chances: Nominated for 3 Oscars

Budget: $350,000

Runtime: 2 Hours 1 Minute

Tagline: They have twelve scraps of paper… Twelve chances to kill!

Overall: One of the greatest films you will ever see.

Rating 95


The Bridge on the River Kwai (1957)

rob challengeThis week on Movie Rob Challenge brings us the multi Oscar winning The Bridge of the River Kwai.

ogoDirector: David Lean

Writer: Carl Foreman, Michael Wilson (Screenplay) Pierre Boulle (Novel)

Starring: William Holden, Alec Guinness, Jack Hawkins, Sessue Hayakawa, James Donald, Geoffrey Horne, Andrew Morell

Plot: After settling his differences with a Japanese PoW camp commander, a British colonel co-operates to oversee his men’s construction of a railway bridge for their captors – while oblivious to a plan by the Allies to destroy it.

There may be spoilers the rest of the review

Verdict: Historical Classic

Story: The Bridge on the River Kwai starts by taking us to the remote Japanese Prisoner or War camp where a fresh batch of English soldiers are being moved in. Colonel Nicholson (Guinness) runs the unit who have to work under Colonel Saito (Hayakawa) as the men are going to be made to build the Bridge of the River Kwai, the camp has no boundaries but escape would see the soldiers head in the a jungle environment with little chance of surviving. Shears (Holden) has been involved in the camp building the camp and being one of the only survivors of the last member of the camp.

It isn’t long till Saito and Nicholson clash when Nicholson tries to play by the rules where officers don’t work in POW camps leading him to face torture until he complies with Saito’s ways. The Japanese want the Burma-Siam railway bridge built and start questioning why it is taking so long and Nicholson continues to hold his ground. After Shears escape he gets forced to return to help sabotage with the British ruining the plans of the Japanese.

The Bridge on the River Kwai is being watched for the very first time in 2015 that is over 50 after its release. I do think that the idea was amazing and showed three different prospectives of war time. We have the Colonel of the prisoner of war camp who goes strict and clashes with a reasonable man and one of his capture who wants to continue his pride while keeping his men busy. We also have an undercover mission to sabotage. The three stories get balanced perfectly and even after being 50 plus years old the only negative thing I found in this film was the over acting. In the end this tells us the story of an amazing part of the war that showed that even though they were enemies they could work together to build something that is constructed perfectly. (9/10)

Actor Review

William Holden: Shears is the American who is a member of the PoW camp who knows the way the plan will go, he manages to escape thinking he is free of the camp forever, but when Major Warden learns of his true identity he gets forced into return with the British to sabotage the construction. William does bring us a great performance filled with the swag of a typical American. (9/10)sshears

Alec Guinness: Colonel Nicholson is the proud English man who refuses to go with the orders of Saito even if it means being tortured until either one folds. Once he gets the upper hand he takes over the construction of the bridge helping improve the ideas of the construction. Alec got an Oscar for his performance but I do feel the final scene is very much over acting. (9/10)nicholson

Jack Hawkins: Major Warden is the man behind the undercover mission who wants to receive updates from anyone who has escaped from the prisoner camp. Warden plans a mission to blow up the bridge and sabotage the railway bridge which includes using Shears to find the location of the PoW. Jack does a good job which is very good showing the true pride in the character. (8/10)warden

Sessue Hayakawa: Colonel Saito is in charge of the prisoner camp who makes sure the prisoners help build a bridge. He doesn’t believe in the normal war rules and is very much a man of honour. Sessue gives us a great performance that shows how disciplined the character has to be in the situation. (9/10)saito

Support Cast: The Bridge on the River Kwai has your typical soldier characters in the prisoner of war camp but hardly any that make much impact on the rest of the story.

Director Review: David Lean – David brings us one of the best war films that isn’t about the conflict of war that balances three stories. (9/10)

War: The Bridge on the River Kwai brings us into the war time that really ends up showing the unite between two men that just have to fight for their country whether they really want too kill the people they are fighting against. (10/10)

Settings: The Bridge on the River Kwai brings us into realistic settings that make us see the environment that the characters end up in. (10/10)

Suggestion: The Bridge on the River Kwai is one that everyone should have watched once in their lives really. (Watch)

Best Part: Final sequence that is really an iconic moment in cinema.

Worst Part: It is long.

Believability: No (0/10)

Chances of Tears: No (0/10)

Chances of Sequel: No

Post Credits Scene: No

Oscar Chances: Won 7 Oscars including Best Picture, Best Actor, Best Director.

Box Office: $27 Million

Budget: $3 Million

Runtime: 2 Hours 41 Minutes

Tagline: It spans a whole new world of entertainment!

Overall: Iconic classic that will always be one that gets talked about by film fans in the subject of war films.

Rating 90